HPC Supports CFTC in Drawing the Line on Event Contracts, Says Prediction Markets Should Be Federally Regulated
Odaily: HPC has submitted a comment letter supporting the two recent rules issued by the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) regarding event contracts, arguing for a clear distinction between federally regulated derivatives and illegal activities regulated by state or tribal law. HPC believes there is a structural difference between event contracts and traditional illegal products: the former are traded on designated contract markets through central order book auctions, with exchanges collecting fees and settlement handled by registered clearing organizations; the latter are priced by bookmakers who set the odds and bear counterparty risk.
On October 19, the CFTC released two companion documents: an interim final rule that excludes illegal gaming offered by state- or tribally-licensed operators outside of exchanges from the definition of regulated swaps; and a proposed rule that explicitly includes event contracts offered by registered exchanges within that definition. HPC supports both rules and recommends further clarifying the scope of state or tribal law, the criteria for determining illegal products, and the definition of event contracts. HPC stated that if states could classify derivatives as illegal based solely on the underlying of the contract, it could lead to derivatives on agricultural products, energy, interest rates, and currencies also being subject to state anti-gambling laws, undermining the CFTC's unified federal regulatory framework for derivatives markets.
